Same contract, 32 clubs, nearly $1 million a year apart from top to bottom.
We put one hypothetical player on each of the 32 NHL clubs, gave him the same salary and his own club's 2026-27 schedule, and prepared every tax return he files: federal, state, provincial and city. We did it at $3 million and again at $8 million. The only thing that changes is the club, and it changes a lot.
- At $8 million, tax takes 40.70% of salary in Dallas and 53.17% in Toronto and Ottawa. Top to bottom, that is $997,376 a year of take-home.
- At $3 million the range is 39.83% (Dallas) to 52.57% (Montreal), and the gap is $382,326.
- The six clubs in states with no income tax on wages (Dallas, Florida, Tampa Bay, Nashville, Seattle and Vegas) finish within $11,757 of each other at $8 million. Carolina, the next club, is another $260,423 back. That is the cliff.
- No state income tax does not mean no state tax. At $8 million the Dallas player still pays other states and cities about $148,000 a year for his road games.
- California taxes almost like Canada. At $8 million an Anaheim player keeps $7,589 more than a Toronto player.
- To leave a player with what a Dallas player keeps at $8 million, the most expensive clubs have to pay him over $10.1 million.
The rankings
All figures in US dollars. Clubs within $100 of each other share a rank. The summary link on each club's row opens that club's one-page summary for that salary (PDF).
Take-home at a $3,000,000 salary
| Rank | Team | Total tax | Take-home | Effective rate | Behind #1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | DAL Dallas Stars US summary | $1,194,802 | $1,805,198 | 39.83% | |
| 2 | FLA Florida Panthers US summary | $1,195,136 | $1,804,864 | 39.84% | $334 |
| 3 | TBL Tampa Bay Lightning US summary | $1,196,646 | $1,803,354 | 39.89% | $1,844 |
| 4 | NSH Nashville Predators US summary | $1,198,439 | $1,801,561 | 39.95% | $3,637 |
| 5 | SEA Seattle Kraken US summary | $1,198,787 | $1,801,213 | 39.96% | $3,985 |
| 6 | VGK Vegas Golden Knights US summary | $1,198,959 | $1,801,041 | 39.97% | $4,157 |
| 7 | CAR Carolina Hurricanes US summary | $1,295,899 | $1,704,101 | 43.20% | $101,097 |
| 8 | COL Colorado Avalanche US summary | $1,296,978 | $1,703,022 | 43.23% | $102,176 |
| 9 | UTA Utah Mammoth US summary | $1,297,629 | $1,702,371 | 43.25% | $102,827 |
| 10 | CHI Chicago Blackhawks US summary | $1,307,187 | $1,692,813 | 43.57% | $112,385 |
| 11 | STL St. Louis Blues US summary | $1,326,431 | $1,673,569 | 44.21% | $131,629 |
| 12 | PIT Pittsburgh Penguins US summary | $1,336,188 | $1,663,812 | 44.54% | $141,386 |
| 13 | CBJ Columbus Blue Jackets US summary | $1,337,425 | $1,662,575 | 44.58% | $142,623 |
| 14 | DET Detroit Red Wings US summary | $1,357,241 | $1,642,759 | 45.24% | $162,439 |
| 15 | PHI Philadelphia Flyers US summary | $1,369,718 | $1,630,282 | 45.66% | $174,916 |
| 16 | BOS Boston Bruins US summary | $1,369,819 | $1,630,181 | 45.66% | $175,017 |
| T-17 | CGY Calgary Flames CAN summary | $1,413,034 | $1,586,966 | 47.10% | $218,232 |
| T-17 | EDM Edmonton Oilers CAN summary | $1,413,034 | $1,586,966 | 47.10% | $218,232 |
| T-19 | BUF Buffalo Sabres US summary | $1,431,434 | $1,568,566 | 47.71% | $236,632 |
| T-19 | NYI New York Islanders US summary | $1,431,442 | $1,568,558 | 47.71% | $236,640 |
| 21 | NJD New Jersey Devils US summary | $1,432,144 | $1,567,856 | 47.74% | $237,342 |
| 22 | MIN Minnesota Wild US summary | $1,436,395 | $1,563,605 | 47.88% | $241,593 |
| 23 | WSH Washington Capitals US summary | $1,447,472 | $1,552,528 | 48.25% | $252,670 |
| 24 | WPG Winnipeg Jets CAN summary | $1,490,912 | $1,509,088 | 49.70% | $296,110 |
| 25 | NYR New York Rangers US summary | $1,547,287 | $1,452,713 | 51.58% | $352,485 |
| 26 | LAK Los Angeles Kings US summary | $1,548,424 | $1,451,576 | 51.61% | $353,622 |
| T-27 | ANA Anaheim Ducks US summary | $1,548,736 | $1,451,264 | 51.62% | $353,934 |
| T-27 | SJS San Jose Sharks US summary | $1,548,736 | $1,451,264 | 51.62% | $353,934 |
| 29 | VAN Vancouver Canucks CAN summary | $1,571,095 | $1,428,905 | 52.37% | $376,293 |
| T-30 | OTT Ottawa Senators CAN summary | $1,577,102 | $1,422,898 | 52.57% | $382,300 |
| T-30 | TOR Toronto Maple Leafs CAN summary | $1,577,102 | $1,422,898 | 52.57% | $382,300 |
| T-30 | MTL Montreal Canadiens CAN summary | $1,577,128 | $1,422,872 | 52.57% | $382,326 |
Take-home at a $8,000,000 salary
| Rank | Team | Total tax | Take-home | Effective rate | Behind #1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | DAL Dallas Stars US summary | $3,256,206 | $4,743,794 | 40.70% | |
| 2 | FLA Florida Panthers US summary | $3,257,794 | $4,742,206 | 40.72% | $1,588 |
| 3 | TBL Tampa Bay Lightning US summary | $3,262,387 | $4,737,613 | 40.78% | $6,181 |
| 4 | NSH Nashville Predators US summary | $3,266,249 | $4,733,751 | 40.83% | $10,043 |
| 5 | SEA Seattle Kraken US summary | $3,267,596 | $4,732,404 | 40.84% | $11,390 |
| 6 | VGK Vegas Golden Knights US summary | $3,267,963 | $4,732,037 | 40.85% | $11,757 |
| 7 | CAR Carolina Hurricanes US summary | $3,528,386 | $4,471,614 | 44.10% | $272,180 |
| 8 | COL Colorado Avalanche US summary | $3,529,696 | $4,470,304 | 44.12% | $273,490 |
| 9 | UTA Utah Mammoth US summary | $3,530,343 | $4,469,657 | 44.13% | $274,137 |
| 10 | CHI Chicago Blackhawks US summary | $3,556,331 | $4,443,669 | 44.45% | $300,125 |
| 11 | STL St. Louis Blues US summary | $3,608,497 | $4,391,503 | 45.11% | $352,291 |
| 12 | PIT Pittsburgh Penguins US summary | $3,633,780 | $4,366,220 | 45.42% | $377,574 |
| 13 | CBJ Columbus Blue Jackets US summary | $3,638,745 | $4,361,255 | 45.48% | $382,539 |
| 14 | DET Detroit Red Wings US summary | $3,690,287 | $4,309,713 | 46.13% | $434,081 |
| 15 | PHI Philadelphia Flyers US summary | $3,722,737 | $4,277,263 | 46.53% | $466,531 |
| 16 | BOS Boston Bruins US summary | $3,792,178 | $4,207,822 | 47.40% | $535,972 |
| T-17 | CGY Calgary Flames CAN summary | $3,813,034 | $4,186,966 | 47.66% | $556,828 |
| T-17 | EDM Edmonton Oilers CAN summary | $3,813,034 | $4,186,966 | 47.66% | $556,828 |
| 19 | MIN Minnesota Wild US summary | $3,909,305 | $4,090,695 | 48.87% | $653,099 |
| T-20 | BUF Buffalo Sabres US summary | $3,935,889 | $4,064,111 | 49.20% | $679,683 |
| T-20 | NYI New York Islanders US summary | $3,935,929 | $4,064,071 | 49.20% | $679,723 |
| 22 | NJD New Jersey Devils US summary | $3,939,563 | $4,060,437 | 49.24% | $683,357 |
| 23 | WSH Washington Capitals US summary | $3,955,518 | $4,044,482 | 49.44% | $699,312 |
| 24 | WPG Winnipeg Jets CAN summary | $4,010,912 | $3,989,088 | 50.14% | $754,706 |
| 25 | MTL Montreal Canadiens CAN summary | $4,242,378 | $3,757,622 | 53.03% | $986,172 |
| 26 | LAK Los Angeles Kings US summary | $4,245,159 | $3,754,841 | 53.06% | $988,953 |
| 27 | NYR New York Rangers US summary | $4,245,589 | $3,754,411 | 53.07% | $989,383 |
| T-28 | ANA Anaheim Ducks US summary | $4,245,993 | $3,754,007 | 53.07% | $989,787 |
| T-28 | SJS San Jose Sharks US summary | $4,245,993 | $3,754,007 | 53.07% | $989,787 |
| 30 | VAN Vancouver Canucks CAN summary | $4,246,095 | $3,753,905 | 53.08% | $989,889 |
| T-31 | TOR Toronto Maple Leafs CAN summary | $4,253,582 | $3,746,418 | 53.17% | $997,376 |
| T-31 | OTT Ottawa Senators CAN summary | $4,253,582 | $3,746,418 | 53.17% | $997,376 |
Salary needed to take home what Dallas pays at $8,000,000
| Rank | Team | Salary needed | Extra vs Dallas | Extra % |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base | DAL Dallas Stars US | $8,000,000 | ||
| 1 | FLA Florida Panthers US | $8,002,703 | $2,703 | 0.03% |
| 2 | TBL Tampa Bay Lightning US | $8,010,528 | $10,528 | 0.13% |
| 3 | NSH Nashville Predators US | $8,017,120 | $17,120 | 0.21% |
| 4 | SEA Seattle Kraken US | $8,019,420 | $19,420 | 0.24% |
| 5 | VGK Vegas Golden Knights US | $8,020,054 | $20,054 | 0.25% |
| 6 | CAR Carolina Hurricanes US | $8,491,493 | $491,493 | 6.14% |
| 7 | COL Colorado Avalanche US | $8,494,009 | $494,009 | 6.18% |
| 8 | UTA Utah Mammoth US | $8,495,138 | $495,138 | 6.19% |
| 9 | CHI Chicago Blackhawks US | $8,545,427 | $545,427 | 6.82% |
| 10 | STL St. Louis Blues US | $8,647,841 | $647,841 | 8.10% |
| 11 | PIT Pittsburgh Penguins US | $8,698,275 | $698,275 | 8.73% |
| 12 | CBJ Columbus Blue Jackets US | $8,708,503 | $708,503 | 8.86% |
| 13 | DET Detroit Red Wings US | $8,813,495 | $813,495 | 10.17% |
| 14 | PHI Philadelphia Flyers US | $8,880,906 | $880,906 | 11.01% |
| 15 | BOS Boston Bruins US | $9,039,658 | $1,039,658 | 13.00% |
| T-16 | CGY Calgary Flames CAN | $9,070,824 | $1,070,824 | 13.39% |
| T-16 | EDM Edmonton Oilers CAN | $9,070,824 | $1,070,824 | 13.39% |
| 18 | MIN Minnesota Wild US | $9,291,868 | $1,291,868 | 16.15% |
| 19 | BUF Buffalo Sabres US | $9,351,874 | $1,351,874 | 16.90% |
| 20 | NYI New York Islanders US | $9,352,072 | $1,352,072 | 16.90% |
| 21 | NJD New Jersey Devils US | $9,370,810 | $1,370,810 | 17.14% |
| 22 | WSH Washington Capitals US | $9,403,162 | $1,403,162 | 17.54% |
| 23 | WPG Winnipeg Jets CAN | $9,521,585 | $1,521,585 | 19.02% |
| 24 | MTL Montreal Canadiens CAN | $10,111,942 | $2,111,942 | 26.40% |
| 25 | VAN Vancouver Canucks CAN | $10,128,793 | $2,128,793 | 26.61% |
| 26 | NYR New York Rangers US | $10,132,354 | $2,132,354 | 26.65% |
| T-27 | OTT Ottawa Senators CAN | $10,146,260 | $2,146,260 | 26.83% |
| T-27 | TOR Toronto Maple Leafs CAN | $10,146,260 | $2,146,260 | 26.83% |
| 29 | LAK Los Angeles Kings US | $10,146,850 | $2,146,850 | 26.84% |
| T-30 | ANA Anaheim Ducks US | $10,149,143 | $2,149,143 | 26.86% |
| T-30 | SJS San Jose Sharks US | $10,149,143 | $2,149,143 | 26.86% |
Why it happens
- Players pay tax where they play. Every road game is taxed by the state it is played in, and sometimes by the city too.
- Home sets the rate. Texas, Florida, Tennessee, Washington and Nevada have no state income tax on wages. California and New York take a big cut.
- Canada taxes everything at Canadian rates. A player on a Canadian club still owes US state and city tax on his road games, but Canada credits it back. For him, home is what counts, not where he plays.
- It does not run the other way. Players on US clubs owe no Canadian tax on games played in Canada, because of the Canada-US tax treaty.
Real contracts aren't this simple
The study's players are deliberately boring: single, salary only, living in the arena city all year. Real players aren't. A signing bonus, escrow, a summer home in another state or in Canada, a spouse, a trade at the deadline: each one moves where the tax lands, and some of them move it a long way.
The tax returns
Here are the full tax returns for two of the 32 players at $8 million: Dallas, the club that keeps the most, and Toronto, tied with Ottawa for the club that pays the most. They are illustrative and for educational purposes only.
Dallas Stars, $8 million (PDF) and Toronto Maple Leafs, $8 million (PDF)
Full return packets for all 32 clubs are available to agents, clubs and media on request.
Study details
- The players. Hypothetical, one per club, at $3 million and $8 million. Single, salary only: no bonuses, escrow or playoff pay. Each lives all year in his club's arena city.
- The schedule. The official 2026-27 regular season, 84 games. Salary is split by games played in each place, plus 12 home training-camp days. The four games in Europe are left out.
- The law. 2025 tax law, the latest available.
- The returns. Canadian clubs were computed in Canadian dollars and converted at 1.388 Canadian dollars per US dollar, the Bank of Canada 2026 average to the end of October.
- The treaty. Players on US clubs owe no Canadian tax on games played in Canada (Canada-US tax treaty, Article XV(2)(b), applied to team athletes by Article XVI(3)).
- Two judgement calls, both small. Washington: DC's credit leaves out Detroit's city tax (about $350 at $3 million). Massachusetts: the deduction for visitors' Social Security and Medicare is prorated to Massachusetts wages.
- How the numbers were made. A combination of commercial tax software, working papers and our own models.
- Frozen. Figures frozen 15 November 2026. The methods note (PDF) has every source and ruling.
- Data. Results (CSV), with its SHA256SUMS. Club detail (JSON): US clubs, Canadian clubs, salary to match Dallas. Fingerprints of every PDF: SHA256SUMS. The whole study as plain text: Markdown.
Can you help with [x]?
Yes. We do this for real players, in real life, for real money. If you have one with a contract on the table, email me: cware@waretax.com.
For journalists
You're welcome to use and quote these figures, with credit: The Real Cap Hit, WareTax, 2026-27 season, waretax.com/nhl. The figures and data are free to use under CC BY 4.0. For an interview, or with questions and corrections, email cware@waretax.com.
Cameron Ware, CPA
Illustration only, not advice. The returns are illustrative and for educational purposes only. WareTax PC is not affiliated with or endorsed by the National Hockey League or any of its clubs. Team names are used for identification only.